I've been eyeing the DeMellier New York tote that's everywhere - but this alternative has saved me hundreds
This luxury bag is a 2025 must-have


I've been eyeing the DeMellier New York bag—a bag on the arm of every fashion influencer and celebrity—but I just can’t justify the price tag and this affordable alternative means I won't have to.
Finding the best designer lookalikes always feels like a win, but this one feels especially good. With the minimalist DeMellier New York Midi tote bag dominating every news feed, it's hard not to feel the pull towards purchasing from the London-based brand loved by Kate Middleton and even Queen Camilla. But as mentioned, parting with almost £500 post-Christmas feels slightly out of reach, so finding this affordable dupe is like striking gold.
The JW PEI Hana Mini Tote delivers the same sleek, structured elegance for a fraction of the cost, and aesthetically they are almost identical. It captures that same sophisticated shape and buttery soft aesthetic, all while staying within the £100 range. Hurrah!
However it's crucial to note, that both the DeMellier New York Midi bag and JW's Hana Tote come in many sizes. If you're wanting slightly more room, JW PEI also offer a medium version and DeMellier offer the New York bag which has a more spacious design than the midi.
DeMellier New York Midi in Black and DeMellier New York Midi in Mocha Suede
DeMellier New York Midi Tote & JW PEI Hana Tote Bag
The Midi New York one of the best designer bags to invest in; with its architectural design and soft leather, you'll get years of wear out of it. Plus, it comes in a range of colours including a tan, a deep burgundy and even an off-white.
Featuring an uncanny resemblance to the New York bag, this faux suede bag will become your new favourite accessory. And it comes in several colourways, from dark olive to a soft latte colour. And now with a site-wide 10% discount (with the code NEW10) it's worth snapping up this beauty quick!
Both bags have a refined, structured silhouette with a slight trapeze shape, making them incredibly versatile. Whether you’re heading to the office, styling a relaxed denim look, or adding a finishing touch to your date night outfit, this bag will be your new wardrobe hero.
The short top handles and subtle gold-tone features also give them a luxurious feel, proving that minimalism doesn’t have to mean boring. It’s the kind of bag that works with everything—tailored blazers, casual denim, or even a floaty spring dress—making it a solid capsule wardrobe staple that you'll wear for years to come.
Of course, there are some key differences, and whilst the DeMellier New York bag is crafted from premium grained leather, giving it a more structured and high-end finish, the JW PEI Hana Mini uses vegan leather, making it a more ethical option.
Sign up for the woman&home newsletter
Sign up to our free daily email for the latest royal and entertainment news, interesting opinion, expert advice on styling and beauty trends, and no-nonsense guides to the health and wellness questions you want answered.
The Hana Mini also leans slightly more compact, which is ideal if you prefer a smaller, easy to carry handbag bag. However, in terms of overall aesthetic they are nearly identical. The JW PEI version truly embodies that designer, luxury feel that so many people are after, that's why this lookalike is such a win.
Molly is a fashion writer for woman&home, whose journalistic career began with her enthusiasm for fashion. Having always been an avid writer, she has contributed to publications covering a variety of topics.
After graduating from her master's in Fashion History and Cultures, she transitioned to teaching at London College of Fashion, where she taught in fashion studies. Now, passionate about writing on the significance of fashion, she is dedicated to inspiring others through the power of dress.
Molly loves staying in the know with the latest fashion trends, and following celebrities for inspiration. Outside of work, she enjoys browsing vintage markets, reading a good novel, or trying new restaurants around London.
-
Refresh your home, protect your loved ones: the finishing touch for a safer Spring
FireAngel is urging homeowners to check their fire alarms and carbon monoxide monitors this Spring with their 'Refresh & Protect' programme
By Laura Honey Published
-
Christine Lampard’s Phase Eight co-ord just revived our confidence for wearing horizontal stripes
Christine Lampard proves beyond doubt that we don't need to daunted by the idea of wearing on-trend horizontal stripes this season
By Emma Shacklock Published
-
Christine Lampard’s Phase Eight co-ord just revived our confidence for wearing horizontal stripes
Christine Lampard proves beyond doubt that we don't need to daunted by the idea of wearing on-trend horizontal stripes this season
By Emma Shacklock Published
-
Demi Moore's houndstooth trench coat was the best alternative to the classic honey colour
We're shopping this season's latest styles just in time for spring
By Molly Smith Published
-
Clodagh McKenna showcased easy breezy high street dressing in M&S and Zara - but her bold belt did the talking
Clodagh McKenna has reminded us that timeless staples and bright accessories are a stunning spring combination
By Emma Shacklock Published
-
Converse low tops are the best trainers to wear with dresses - I even wore them on my wedding day!
This classic canvas style is currently just £30 on Amazon
By Antonia Kraskowski Published
-
Elegant, elevated and aspirational - here's why we're shopping Hobbs SS25 occasionwear collection just in time for spring
From vibrant florals to muted powder blues this collection has it all
By Molly Smith Published
-
Can a minimiser bra be both comfortable and supportive? Here's what I think of the Bravissimo Cici Non Wired Bra
Will this bra deliver on support and style?
By Julie Player Published
-
Lorraine Kelly exudes class in cocoa-toned dress with slip-on shoes as she blends elegance and comfort
Lorraine Kelly has found a high street gem with her brown & Other Stories dress and her slip-on shoes complete the chic ensemble
By Emma Shacklock Published
-
This M&S coat could pass for Burberry – and no one would know the difference
Purchase now for £75, but sizes are selling fast, so hurry!
By Molly Smith Published